Delaware Court of Chancery history
The Delaware Court of Chancery traces its heritage to medieval England and stands as one of the oldest continuously operating courts of equity in the United States. Unlike traditional courts of law, the Court of Chancery was founded as a court of equity — a distinction that has shaped its procedures, its jurisdiction, and its extraordinary influence on American corporate law for more than two centuries. That long history has made the court a central institution not only for Delaware but for the national and global business community, as the vast majority of publicly traded American corporations are incorporated in Delaware and therefore subject to the court's jurisdiction.[1]
Origins and English Heritage
The concept of a court of equity distinct from common law courts originated in medieval England. Traditional English common law courts were bound by strict procedural rules and could offer only limited remedies, primarily monetary damages. When litigants believed that the common law produced unjust outcomes, they could petition the King's Chancellor — originally an ecclesiastical official — for relief based on principles of fairness and conscience. Over time, this practice gave rise to the Court of Chancery in England, a separate tribunal empowered to grant remedies such as injunctions and orders for specific performance that were unavailable at common law.
This English model was transplanted to the American colonies and eventually to the state of Delaware. The Delaware General Assembly established the state's Court of Chancery to hear disputes where equitable remedies were needed — cases involving trusts, fiduciary duties, injunctions, and matters where monetary damages alone would be inadequate. The court operates without juries; instead, judges known as chancellors and vice chancellors hear cases and render decisions based on the facts and equitable principles at issue.[2] This structure — a bench of specialized jurists deciding complex civil business disputes without juries — became a defining characteristic that attracted corporations seeking predictable and expert adjudication.
Establishment and Early Development
The Delaware Court of Chancery has operated for well over two centuries, with its history stretching back to the founding era of the American republic. As of 2014, the court had been in continuous operation for 222 years, making it one of the oldest equity courts in continuous operation in the United States.[3] During its early decades, the court handled the full range of equity matters common to a developing American state — disputes over land, trusts, estates, and transactions where parties sought relief that courts of common law could not provide.
A critical component of Delaware's eventual economic development was the creation and cultivation of this specialized business court, charged with resolving disputes arising from corporate activity in an expert and efficient manner.[4] As Delaware's corporate law framework developed in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries — particularly following the adoption of its permissive General Corporation Law — the Court of Chancery became increasingly central to the interpretation and enforcement of those laws.
Role as the Nation's Business Court
Over the course of the twentieth century, the Delaware Court of Chancery became the primary judicial forum for resolving corporate disputes in the United States. Because Delaware is the state of incorporation for a large proportion of publicly traded American companies, the court regularly hears cases involving mergers, acquisitions, fiduciary duty claims, shareholder rights, and internal governance disputes. Its judges develop deep expertise in corporate law, and the body of precedent they produce is closely studied by lawyers, executives, and scholars across the country and abroad.
The court has earned a reputation as the nation's business court, a designation that reflects both its caseload and its influence on corporate legal doctrine.[5] The court attracts numerous companies that have incorporated in Delaware, and its chancellors sort out civil business disputes without the involvement of juries — a feature that allows for nuanced, technically sophisticated decisions in complex commercial matters.[6]
The court's docket has historically included high-profile litigation involving major corporate transactions. Among the significant categories of cases the court has addressed are disputes over merger agreements where parties have sought to back out of deals — known colloquially as deal bust-ups — as well as cases involving the fiduciary duties of corporate directors under the so-called Caremark standard, which governs director oversight obligations.[7] These decisions have shaped the expectations placed on corporate boards across the United States.
Notable Moments and Precedents
The Court of Chancery's long history includes a number of notable moments that illustrate both its reach and its limits. In 2014, the court took a step that, according to a court administrator with nearly three decades of experience, had apparently never occurred before in the court's 222-year history: it issued an arrest warrant. The warrant was directed at Huey Shen Wu of Newark, Delaware, who had been accused by his former employer, W.L. Gore & Associates, of misappropriating trade secrets related to the company's Gore-Tex polymer fabrics. Vice Chancellor Donald Parsons Jr. issued the warrant after Wu failed to comply with court orders and requests for appearances. Wu faced contempt of court charges and a possible jail sentence for failing to surrender his United States passport and foreign travel documents. Kenneth Lagowski, a chancery office administrator with 29 years of service, stated that there were no records of another arrest warrant having been issued in the court's long history.[8]
The court has also been the venue for some of the longest-running litigation in recent memory. In one such proceeding, a plaintiff class that had brought claims against a corporation ultimately lost at trial after years of litigation, illustrating both the court's capacity for extended, complex proceedings and the uncertainty that accompanies high-stakes corporate litigation.[9]
The Arbitration Experiment
A significant, if short-lived, chapter in the court's history involved an attempt to expand its role into private dispute arbitration. In 2009, the Delaware legislature amended state law to permit the Court of Chancery to arbitrate private disputes confidentially, without the proceedings being open to public scrutiny.[10] The program was designed to offer businesses an alternative to traditional litigation — a confidential, expert proceeding conducted by the court's experienced jurists.
However, the confidentiality of the program drew legal challenges from parties who argued that court proceedings must be open to the public under the First Amendment. The program was ultimately struck down, ending what came to be described as Delaware's arbitration experiment.[11] The episode demonstrated both the court's willingness to adapt and expand its services to meet the demands of the business community, and the constitutional constraints that limit the ways in which judicial institutions can operate outside of public view.
Physical Home
Like any institution of its age, the Court of Chancery has operated from different physical locations over the centuries. Based in Wilmington, Delaware, the court's facilities have evolved over time to accommodate its growing docket and staff. The court's move to a new facility in the early 2000s attracted attention as a reflection of the institution's continued importance and the investment the state of Delaware makes in maintaining its premier judicial forum for business disputes.[12]
Challenges and Competition
The Delaware Court of Chancery's dominant position in corporate law has not gone unchallenged. Competing states have periodically sought to attract corporate incorporations by developing their own specialized business courts and modernizing their corporate statutes. Texas, in particular, has made deliberate efforts to court re-incorporations in the Lone Star State, and has specifically designed its efforts to challenge the Delaware Court of Chancery's preeminence.[13] The phenomenon of companies leaving Delaware incorporation — sometimes referred to informally as "Dexit" — reflects ongoing competitive pressures on the Delaware corporate law ecosystem.
These competitive pressures have intensified debate about whether the Court of Chancery can maintain its central role in American corporate governance, or whether states with growing economies and improving judicial infrastructure can meaningfully replicate the depth of expertise and precedent that the Delaware court has accumulated over more than two centuries.[14]
Legacy
The Delaware Court of Chancery occupies a singular place in the history of American law. Founded as a court of equity with roots in medieval English legal tradition, it has evolved over more than two centuries into the primary judicial forum for corporate disputes in the United States. Its bench of specialized jurists, its vast body of precedent, and its procedures — including the absence of juries in civil business disputes — have made it the institution against which other business courts in the country are measured.[15]
The court's history includes landmark moments of institutional adaptation, such as the short-lived arbitration program, as well as historic firsts, such as the 2014 arrest warrant that had no recorded precedent in the court's long existence. As competitive pressures from other states intensify and as the landscape of corporate governance continues to evolve, the Court of Chancery's history remains both a foundation for its present authority and a subject of ongoing scholarly and legal attention.